Friday, November 21, 2014

Do the Infancy Narratives Contradict?

Back in college, near Christmas break in 2007, Kari and I heard the worst sermon ever given.  The priest approached the pulpit and basically said, "You know, the infancy narratives contradict one another. Try not to take any of this too seriously. Let's all just act in a Christian manner by being nice to people."


But tis the season, and I thought I'd take on the question of whether the infancy narratives contradict one another.  So if Biblical chronology is your thing, I have a treat for you!

The Data:

On face value, the infancy narratives found in Luke and Matthew seem to tell vastly different and incompatible stories.

Luke’s Gospel says the following:

  • The Holy Family traveled from Nazareth to Bethlehem. [Luke 2:4]
  • Jesus was born in Bethlehem in a cave or stable with animals. [Luke 2:7]
  • He is taken up to the Temple in Jerusalem forty days later for a purification ritual.  [Luke 2:22]
  • The Holy Family is said to return to Nazareth. [Luke 2:39]

Matthew's Gospel tells us something very different:  

  • The Magi visit Mary and Jesus in a house in Bethlehem. [Matt 2:11]
  • Almost immediately thereafter the Holy Family flees to Egypt to evade Herod's murderous intentions. [Matt 2:14]  
  • They stayed there until they learned of Herod's death - at which time they returned to Nazareth. [Matt 2:23]

So people will ask:
"Was Jesus born in a house or in a stable?"  
"Did they have to quickly flee or did they have time to visit Jerusalem?”

I Blame Manger Scenes:

This confusion is largely the result of the common depiction of the nativity found in manger scenes.  These give people the impression that the Magi were present at the birth of Jesus. 

But this is not what the Bible says.  

Matthew’s Gospel says the Magi didn’t begin the journey to Bethlehem until after Jesus was born:  
“When Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea, in the days of King Herod, magi from the east arrived in Jerusalem…” - Matthew 2:1
 And when they told Herod about the newborn king, it says Herod discerned the age of the child to be about two years:
“When Herod realized that he had been deceived by the magi, he became furious. He ordered the massacre of all the boys in Bethlehem and its vicinity two years old and under, in accordance with the time he had ascertained from the magi.” – Matthew 2:16
So between Luke and Matthew there would have been a two year gap of time.  This is more than long enough to accommodate getting a house and obeying the Mosaic precepts for childbirth.    

A New Problem:

However, this makes one last problem emerge.  If you read straight from Luke 2:22 to 2:40, you'd be left with the impression that the Holy Family returned to Nazareth after their business in Jerusalem was concluded.  
"When they had fulfilled all the prescriptions of the law of the Lord, they returned to Galilee, to their own town of Nazareth.” – Luke 2:39
So why did the Magi find them in a house in Jerusalem 2 years later?

The U-Haul Solution:

The first solution I would propose is the simplest:   Sometime during that two year gap, the Holy Family moved to Bethlehem to set up a permanent residence.  

There are three reasons why one would find this reasonable.  First, in Luke 2:4 we learn that Bethlehem was Joseph’s ancestral hometown, so this wouldn’t be entirely new territory for him.

Also, in Luke 2:41 we see that the Holy Family made yearly trips to Jerusalem.  Being 6 miles from Jerusalem instead of 65 miles would have made the trip far easier.

Lastly, for reasons having to do with the inexplicable nature of Mary’s pregnancy, they may have found it best to avoid the scandal of living at home and moving to a place where they would be more anonymous.

So all one has to imagine is that sometime during those 40 days they spent in Bethlehem, Joseph found employment, located a house, and said to Mary:
“Hey, let’s get our stuff from Nazareth and move back here.”
Under this theory, the final map of the Holy Family’s travels would look like this:

The Gloss Solution:

The second solution is drawn from the historical writing style of Saint Luke.  He had no qualms against skipping large sections of time and not telling you about it.  

One example happens between Acts 9:25 and Acts 9:26. It says Paul escaped Damascus and went to Jerusalem.  But in Galatians 1:15-18 you read that after Paul escaped from Damascus he went to Arabia, returned to Damascus for 3 years, and then finally traveled to Jerusalem.   But if you just read the text of Acts 9:25-26, you’d never know there were 3 years between those two verses.

Thus, this solution proposes that Luke 2:39 - while appearing to offer an airtight summation of what happened after Christ’s purification - is in reality a gloss over a large section of His life.  Luke’s goal of this passage was simply to let you know that Jesus grew up in Nazareth before moving on.  

In that case, the final map of the Holy Family’s journey would look like this:

In either case, we can say the following with certainty.  Each author only gives a partial account of Jesus’ early life.  Even when taken together you still have some gaps to fill in to resolve some quandaries.  However, the text is not in direct contradiction.

Thank you for joining me.

Addendum:  Tim Staples of Catholic Answers gave another possible solution today on their blog.

"The Wise Men were 'sent' to Bethlehem by Herod, but the text never says that is where they ended up. We know, in fact, they would have ended up in Nazareth where Christ actually was, not Bethlehem."

1 comment:

  1. There are people who doubt about this, and some say it was the mistake of the authors of the Gospels. But in my opinion I understand that the authors of the two Gospels were not mistaken. Just not fully described Consider carefully. Taking the passages of the two Gospels into consideration. I have an opinion that the story should be as follows.

    According to the text of St. Luke - after all fulfillment of the law at the temple in Jerusalem. The Holy Family was determined to return to Nazareth. But traveling on a long journey is not easy(The distance from Bethlehem to Nazareth is 65 kilometers), you have to get your belongings ready, especially when accompanied by a baby boy. To provide Fuud supplies, water, clothing, etc., St. Joseph had to buy things in Jerusalem and went to say goodbye to Elizabeth. This would take quite a long time until the afternoon Which is not easy to travel. So, Joseph took the baby and the mother back to Bethlehem first to rest and set out the next day. At night it was just as the Magi arrived and worshiped the baby Jesus and made a tribute. The Magi was told by the angel in his dreams to return by another route. Afterward, St. Joseph was also warned by a dream angel to take the baby and mother to flee Egypt. Traveling to Egypt was no problem. Because St. Joseph had already prepared the supplies(The distance from Bethlehem to Egypt is approximately 140 kilometers). They immediately set out to Egypt, which is south of Israel. The Magi returned home to the east of Israel.

    On that day many important events took place in Jerusalem and Bethlehem. At Jerusalem, Christ showed Himself to the Jews. With Simeon and Anna as representatives. And on the same day, at Bethlehem, Christ presented Himself to the Gentiles. With the three Magi representing